Mumbai, January 18, 2024: “Main Atal Hoon,” the biopic of India’s 10th Prime Minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, has landed in theaters, stirring mixed reactions from critics. Pankaj Tripathi’s captivating portrayal of Vajpayee is the film’s undeniable highlight, earning praise for its nuanced approach and emotional depth. However, the film’s screenplay and overall direction find themselves under scrutiny, sparking debate about its historical accuracy and narrative choices.
Triumphant Tripathi: The unanimous winner in the critical landscape is Tripathi. His transformation into Vajpayee is lauded as near-magical, capturing the statesman’s mannerisms, voice, and quiet charm with remarkable authenticity. The Indian Express states, “Tripathi inhabits Vajpayee’s spirit, his quietude and eloquence, his vulnerability and strength.” News18 echoes this sentiment, calling his performance “pitch-perfect” and “the soul of the film.”
A Patchwork of Praise and Critique: While Tripathi’s performance takes center stage, the film’s structure and storytelling face criticism. Firstpost finds the narrative “slow-paced” and “lacking depth,” arguing that key historical events like the Pokhran Tests and Kargil War are “glossed over.” The Quint agrees, calling the first half a “history lesson” and the second half bordering on “political propaganda.” However, reviewers like Times of India praise the film’s emotional resonance, appreciating its focus on Vajpayee’s personal struggles and poetic side.
A Conversation on Legacy: Despite its flaws, “Main Atal Hoon” sparks an important conversation about Vajpayee’s legacy. The film delves into his political journey, showcasing his rise from poet to Prime Minister, and highlighting his complex relationship with his party and opposition. While some critics question the film’s historical accuracy, others applaud its attempt to humanize a towering political figure.
Overall Verdict: “Main Atal Hoon” is a film with a divided reputation. Pankaj Tripathi’s exceptional performance elevates the film, but the uneven narrative and questionable historical liberties leave room for debate. Ultimately, it’s a film that invites audiences to engage with Vajpayee’s life and legacy, sparking conversations about leadership, poetry, and the complexities of Indian politics.
Box Office Expectations: Despite the mixed reviews, “Main Atal Hoon” is expected to perform well at the box office, driven by Tripathi’s star power and Vajpayee’s enduring popularity. Early audience reports suggest a positive reception, particularly among fans of the late Prime Minister.
